Shovel pass is a common play used around the goal line in the NFL. This article provides in depth analysis of the concept, starting with no QB run threat, along with several other variations of the Shovel Option Concept.
Shovel option is a combination of Power blocking along with option principles. Traditionally, as seen here, the backside Guard pulls through the hole up to the second level. The Center and playside Guard down block. The playside Tackle leaves #96 Outside Linebacker Mike Neal and also goes up to the second level. Mike Neal is the “read” man. If Neal widens with QB Carson Palmer’s half roll, Palmer will flip the shovel pass underneath to a scraping Larry Fitzgerald.
The underneath shovel pass concept has multiple variations. In a 2-man scheme, the shovel man and QB (as a runner) are threats:
Credit: From James Light Football’s Boston College Shovel Option Series at http://jameslightfootball.com/2015/08/07/boston-college-shovel-option-series/
Next, shovel can be a triple option with the underneath shovel man, the QB, and a running back or receiver as an outside pitch option reading two defenders.
Finally, shovel triple option can be run with a flat route as a shovel triple option with a pass element, or quadruple option:
Credit: from Smartfootball’s Shovel Option with a sprintout at http://smartfootball.com/option/combining-the-shovel-option-with-a-sprint-out-pass#sthash.40cBKg8n.dpbs
Here, Bruce Arians combines elements of these versions to create a well designed and somewhat unique shovel pass. Note, there is no speed option element to this play, and it is not triple option. Running back David Johnson (#31) never looks for the ball or gets into pitch phase. He is a decoy. Johnson’s flow outside moves the defense slightly to the outside, particularly #47 Linebacker Jake Ryan. QB Carson Palmer is not a run threat in this scheme.
Wideout John Brown (#12) also goes in motion and then runs a flat route. This accomplishes two things: first, it helps diagnose the coverage. More importantly, it brings his original man-to-man defender across the formation and out of position to tackle the underneath shovel. Brown could also potentially be a pass option in the flat if the defense does not account for him.
Fitzgerald’s pre-snap alignment along with the blocking scheme makes it impossible for his man-to-man defender (#37 Sam Shields) to make a play on him. If Mike Neal squeezed inside to the shovel pass, it’s possible Palmer could have looked for Nelson, or just thrown it at Fitzgerald’s feet. Overall, it’s a great example of Bruce Arians adapting a scheme to fit personnel.
Andy Reid has also implemented plenty of shovel concepts. Below, he uses jet motion window dressing and a power read mesh to cause confusion set up a shovel option touchdown:
Reid uses the same concept below without any jet motion and the threat of a toss to speedster Tyreek Hill to expand the defense:
To learn more about the triple option shovel pass, below is an instructional video:
Along with compilations of Urban Meyer’s shovel triple option both at Utah and Florida: